Prosecutors defend Weinstein recording decision

Prosecutors have defended their decision not to press charges against Harvey Weinstein after an Italian model claimed she was sexually assaulted by the Hollywood producer.

In March 2015, Ambra Battilana Gutierrez told police that Weinstein invited to her to his New York City office and touched her inappropriately.

Detectives then launched a sting operation and asked Ms Gutierrez, 22, to agree to meet the producer while wearing a hidden microphone.

In a recording published by The New Yorker, Weinstein can be heard trying to persuade the model to enter his hotel room.


The New Yorker has released a copy of an audio recording  which was reportedly made at the entrance to Harvey Weinstein's hotel room

Video:
US magazine puts out Weinstein recording

:: Harvey Weinstein – Accusers, critics and defenders

Gutierrez is heard telling Weinstein clearly she is “not comfortable” with the situation as he tells her repeatedly to come and sit next to him and to go to the bathroom after saying he is going to have a shower.

Manhattan district attorney Cyrus Vance has said he was “sickened” by the audio, but added he felt it was not enough to secure a conviction.

He said: “At the end of the day we operate in a courtroom of law not the court of public opinion.

Harvey Weinstein and his wife Georgina Chapman
Image:
Harvey Weinstein has been left by his wife Georgina Chapman

“Our sex crime prosecutors made a determination that this was not going to be a provable case, and so the decision was made not to go forward.

“Obviously he has some serious issues, and the tape is terrible.”

Mr Vance added that the Hollywood mogul’s status and donations to the Democratic Party had nothing to do with his decision.

He said: “If we had a case that we felt we could prosecute and my experts felt we could prosecute against Harvey Weinstein, we would have.


Louisette Geiss alleges that Weinstein performed a sex act in front of her

Video:
Actress says Weinstein performed sex act in front of her

“We take on many, many, many difficult sex crime prosecutions with individuals irrespective of their background or their money so that’s not an issue for us.”

In a statement, New York City Police Department criticised Mr Vance, saying the audio recording “was just one aspect of the case” against Weinstein.

It added: “The detectives used well established investigative techniques.

“The recorded conversation with the subject corroborates the acts that were the basis for the victim’s complaint to the police a day earlier.”


1996 GWYNETH PALTROW STARS IN 'THE PALLBEARER'
1996 GWYNETH PALTROW STARS IN 'THE PALLBEARER'

Video:
The actresses who claim Weinstein harassed or assaulted them

Weinstein has been left by his wife, British fashion designer Georgina Chapman, amid claims he raped three women.

Meanwhile, Gwyneth Paltrow, Angelina Jolie and a string of other Hollywood stars have accused the producer of making unwanted advances towards them.

British model and actress Cara Delevingne has claimed Weinstein asked her to kiss another woman before later trying to kiss her on the lips during a meeting about a film.

The producer continues to “unequivocally deny” allegations of non-consensual sex against him and of illegal sexual harassment.



Video:
The treatment of women in Hollywood

On Wednesday, police were called to his daughter’s Los Angeles home amid reports Weinstein was seen in the middle of the road outside.

Los Angeles Police Department said its officers responded to calls of a “disturbance” but left after “it was revealed there was no crime and it was a family dispute”.

Leave a Reply

...