I spent the pre-dawn hours of Sunday morning driving around Barcelona; bouncing from polling station to polling station talking to excited, determined, anxious and wet Catalans.
In the pouring rain they had gathered at schools and other public buildings across this disputed region of Spain.
For a proportion of the 7.5 million people of Catalonia, this was their moment.
There had been referenda before, but they were just temperature tests; signals to the central government of the sentiment, but not binding.
This was different.
The regional coalition government – populated by a broad spectrum of politicians from centre-right to far-left and voted in with less than 50% of the popular vote in the last regional elections – pledged a binding referendum and passed a formal bill authorising it.
For the first time, Catalans who wanted a say were being given their chance: formally, democratically and – in the regional government’s view – legally too.
:: Catalonia referendum: The fight for independence explained

Crowds scatter as rubber balls fired by police
But in Madrid, the centre-right government of Mariano Rajoy saw it as an illegal insurgency to split up an “indissoluble” nation state: Spain.
Constitutionally they were right. Spain’s highest court ruled the vote illegal.
“They’re calling you ‘insurgents’,” I said to a middle-aged man, dripping, outside one school.
“Yes, and I am proud of that,” he replied.
“If a law is wrong, a man is not only right to disobey it, he is also obliged to do so,” he added, quoting something attributed – with some doubt – to Thomas Jefferson.
On reflection, given the history of resentment, the opportunity the referendum presented and the immovable positions of both sides, it was always likely to be difficult.
Still, there is something deeply chilling about what unfolded.

The vote fell well short of any international election standard
Put the politics aside; leave the vital and consequential issues of legality and legitimacy of the vote for another conversation and absorb what happened.
On the orders of a European Union government, riot police brutally suppressed thousands of people who were attempting peacefully to express their will in a democratic process.
I saw them stamp on voters, beat them with batons, fire rubber bullets at them.
It was brutal, and against a peaceful movement.
The Madrid government claims the vote was a sham. They say they were protecting a greater democracy by trying to stop it.
“Democracy is not above the rule of law, democracy is guaranteed by the rule of law,” Spain’s foreign minister, Alfonso Dastis, told us on Saturday.

Spain’s foreign minister questioned on violence
As the violence continued on Sunday night, I interviewed him again.
He was sitting in his office in Madrid and seemed unaware or in denial about what had unfolded in Catalonia.
“I am not sure I have seen the same pictures that you seem to have seen,” he said.
“Our position is that if there has been any violence at all we have tried for it to be proportional and, in any case, trying to discharge what the courts asked the police to do, which is to prevent the referendum from taking place.”
He suggested that fake news had played a part. A low, weak retort which made him look foolish.
“If they [the police] tried to disrupt the voting, that is because that vote was not supposed to take place,” Mr Dastis added.
“And it was only because of the insistence of the government of Catalonia to simply, you know, disregard the law and act against the rules that guarantees our democracy that these things are taking place.”
So what happens now?
International monitors invited by the Catalan government to monitor the process were shocked by what they saw.
One of them, Knesia Svetliva, from Israel, was next to me as the police fired their rubber bullets.
She said she’d seen that sort of thing in the Middle East. “But in the EU?!” she said.














Leave a reply