Ten years ago this month, a Wisconsin judge gave Steven Avery's legal team something they had been pushing hard for: permission to put the physical evidence from his murder case back under the microscope. For viewers of Netflix's Making a Murderer, it felt like the start of a new chapter. A decade later, it is worth looking at what that order actually allowed, what came of it, and where the case now stands.

The case in brief
Teresa Halbach, a 25-year-old photographer, disappeared on 31 October 2005 after a work visit to the Avery family's salvage yard in Manitowoc County, Wisconsin. Her RAV4 was later found on the property, and her remains were recovered nearby.
The case drew national attention because of who was charged. Steven Avery had been freed in 2003 after DNA evidence cleared him of a sexual assault he did not commit, having served 18 years. At the time of Halbach's disappearance he was suing Manitowoc County over that wrongful conviction. In 2007 he was convicted of her murder and sentenced to life without parole. His nephew, Brendan Dassey, who was 16 when detectives questioned him, was convicted in a separate trial largely on the strength of his own confession, and received a life sentence with the possibility of parole in 2048.

Making a Murderer, released in December 2015, questioned both convictions and turned the case into a worldwide talking point. Its central claim, that police may have planted evidence, has always been rejected by the investigators involved and by prosecutors.
What the November 2016 order did
In late November 2016, Judge Angela Sutkiewicz, the Sheboygan County judge overseeing Avery's post-conviction case, approved an agreement between Avery's lawyer, Kathleen Zellner, and the Wisconsin Department of Justice. It allowed new, independent scientific testing of items from the case. Much of it centred on Halbach's RAV4, including the blood found inside the vehicle.

Two details are often missed:
- It was agreed, not imposed. The state did not oppose the testing. The order set out how it would be done, rather than the court ruling against prosecutors.
- Avery paid for it. The order specified that the testing would be at his own expense, not the state's.
In other words, the order was a door opening, not a verdict. It gave the defence a chance to look for new evidence; it said nothing about whether that evidence would help.
What happened next for Steven Avery

The new testing did not lead to a new trial. In October 2017, Judge Sutkiewicz denied Zellner's motion for one, and further motions and appeals over the following years failed too.
Avery's most recent state appeal argued that someone else killed Teresa Halbach and that the jury should have been allowed to hear evidence pointing to that person. The Wisconsin Court of Appeals rejected it, describing the evidence as speculative. On 21 May 2025 the Wisconsin Supreme Court declined to review the case in a one-sentence order, closing off his remaining routes in the state courts. Zellner said afterwards that she expected the decision and would look at a federal habeas corpus petition.
In September 2026, Avery also applied to have his sentence commuted, the same route his nephew is now taking.
Brendan Dassey's long road

Dassey came closer to freedom than Avery ever has. In August 2016, a federal magistrate judge ruled that his confession had been involuntary and overturned his conviction. A federal appeals panel upheld that ruling in 2017, but the full Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals reversed it by a 4–3 vote that December. In June 2018 the US Supreme Court declined to hear his case, and his conviction stood.

Dassey then asked for a pardon. In 2019, Governor Tony Evers said he would not consider one, because Dassey had not completed his sentence.
That is why his latest request is for commutation, not a pardon. The difference matters: a pardon forgives a conviction, while a commutation only shortens a sentence. Dassey's conviction would stand either way. His application, submitted in September 2026, goes before the governor's commutation advisory board on Friday 11 December 2026. The board will make a recommendation, and Evers, who is not seeking a third term, will make the final decision.

What to watch for
- 11 December 2026: the commutation board considers Dassey's request. Any decision then rests with Governor Evers.
- Avery's commutation bid: his application has been filed but, at the time of writing, had not been scheduled for a hearing.
- A federal challenge: Avery's lawyer has said a federal habeas petition is her next legal step, though no timetable has been given.
Whatever happens next, the 2016 re-testing order is a useful reminder of how slowly these cases move. A ruling that made headlines around the world began a process that, ten years later, has still not changed the outcome for either man. And through all of it, a young woman's family has been living with the loss of Teresa Halbach.
Sources
- Star Tribune: judge orders new testing of Steven Avery evidence (November 2016)
- WBAY: Steven Avery's appeal turned down by Wisconsin Supreme Court (21 May 2025)
- FOX 11: Avery's bid to present alternate-suspect evidence rejected
- Wisconsin Law Journal: Steven Avery, Brendan Dassey seek commutations (September 2026)
- WSAW: Brendan Dassey gets date for commutation hearing (17 November 2026)
- Wisconsin State Journal: Tony Evers won't pardon Brendan Dassey (2019)














Leave a reply