Gender-biased rankings can sink a great TV show.
There’s a time and a place for No Girls Allowed, and it’s called G.R.O.S.S.

If you don’t belong to that club — and it’s likely you don’t, considering the only two members are a fictional kid and his stuffed tiger — then it’s not time for No Girls Allowed and therefore not your job to methodically erase women’s opinions on the internet.
I’m referring to an IMDb analysis done by the London-based writer Marcus Beard that was published in August on the film site One Room With A View. The article’s thrust was this: Men and women tend to prefer different movies (gasp). Beard also pointed out that IMDb’s “Top Movies” might be an inaccurate list simply because so few women take the time to rate movies on IMDb.
Let’s put that in actual numbers:
- Men accounted for 81% of ratings on IMDb; women for just 19%.
- Only 296 films were rated more by women than by men.
- 14,043 were rated more by men than by women.
- Only 41 were rated by an equal number of guys and gals.
Think of those stats as you like. Good, bad or indifferent, they are what they are. It doesn’t trouble me so much that IMDb is representative of the male cinematic taste (after all, nobody is barring women from getting on the site; they’re just choosing not to). What bothersme is the almost throwaway stat Beard includes about the all-female 2016 “Ghostbusters”remake:

“‘Ghostbusters’ proves how polarized IMDb ratings can be — though our suspicion is that both sides mostly were rating to make a point, rather than reflecting their opinions. That’s backed up by the fact that 45% of women voting on ‘Ghostbusters’ rated it 10/10 and 35% of men voted it 1/10.”
More than a third of men really thought the movie was a 1/10? So for every three guys who watched that movie, one of them thought it couldn’t have been any worse? Really?
I’m not sure I buy that. I’m more inclined to agree with Beard’s suspicion that each side was voting ideologically.
The question is: Why?
Shady ratings
Beard’s piece linked to a FiveThirtyEight article by Walt Hickey which confirms what I suspected from the “Ghostbusters”example: Men are deliberately torpedoing movies and shows made for women.
Hickey writes:
“We can quibble about where it stands in the TV canon, but “Sex and the City” has seven Emmys and a suite of Golden Globes and Screen Actors Guild awards. It ran 94 episodes through six seasons on a premium cable network. Any reasonable person should concede that “Sex and the City” was an above-average television program (at minimum).















Leave a reply