Facebook’s internal guidelines on what’s acceptable – and what’s not – to publish on its platform show a company that is struggling to deal with its own massive reach.
There’s no smoking gun in the documents, published by the Guardian newspaper: they don’t differ hugely from the guidelines it publishes. But they offer an insight into just how tricky these issues are – and show some inconsistencies on the grey areas.
Dealing with millions of flagged posts is a team of just 4,500 moderators – although as Mark Zuckerberg recently announced in his own Facebook post, 3,000 more will be joining them.
That’s a total of 7,500 moderators for nearly 2 billion users.
Zuckerberg on Facebook video gunman killing
Some of the details seem shocking on first sight – namely that Facebook won’t necessarily remove images of violent death, non-sexual abuse of children and self-harm.
For each, though, there’s a counterargument.
Violent death might be part of a news story that deserves an audience. Non-sexual abuse or bullying of children is allowed so long as there is no sadistic or celebratory element – again, creating awareness of a problem might override that.
And with live-streaming self-harm, Facebook’s response is in fact quite nuanced: “We don’t want to censor or punish people in distress who are attempting suicide,” the Guardian reports. “Experts have told us what’s best for these people’s safety is to let them live-stream as long as they are engaging with viewers.”
And beyond all of these instances is a concern not to act as a global censor.















Leave a reply